The EU Council has a negotiating mandate on AI and personal data. It is not a statute, and noyb's reading is not the Council's press release.
The EU Council agreed an October 21 negotiating position, not a statute. A tracker prints Article 88bis on AI. noyb calls it expropriation. Parliament has not agreed.
The short version
The Council says it agreed a negotiating position on October 21, 2026, not a finished law. A tracker of document ST 13886/26 prints a draft Article 88bis: AI-related processing may use legitimate interest, the duty to choose a lawful ground remains, and safeguards include the right to object. noyb says the draft lets company interests trump privacy. Parliament has not agreed.
A position, then a fight about a paragraph
The Council of the European Union said on October 21, 2026 that it had agreed its position on a proposal to simplify certain data-protection, privacy, and cybersecurity rules, as part of a package it calls Omnibus VII. The release says the press note was updated on October 22 with the text of the mandate. It says the goal is a clearer rulebook and that protection of personal data stays in place. noyb's October 23 post says member states approved a change that would put AI companies' profit ahead of the right to data protection, and it points at a Council text published the next day. EUTechReg prints Article 88bis from a document it identifies as ST 13886/26. Three layers: a press release, a printed article, and an advocacy reading. This page does not flatten them.a penalty order is a different document.
The three paragraphs, as the tracker prints them
The tracker says paragraph 1 provides that processing personal data in the context of developing or operating an AI system or model may be carried out for a legitimate interest of the controller or a third party, under the existing legitimate-interest ground. Paragraph 2 says that does not affect the controller's obligation to choose an appropriate lawful ground. Paragraph 3 says that whatever the ground, AI-related processing shall have appropriate technical and organisational measures and safeguards, including the right to object. The tracker dates the article's addition to a September Council text and a change on October 2. This page has not re-typed the Council PDF. It is relying on the tracker's printing and on the Council's press summary. If those diverge, the Council document wins, and this row should be corrected.what a session cannot be.
noyb's reading, labeled
noyb says the legitimate-interest sentence means companies may use personal data, including data collected years ago from people who are not customers, as long as the use is in the context of AI, and that consent is not required. It says the nods to the right to object and to organisational measures add nothing, because those duties already apply. It says the Council text also narrows personal data through pseudonymisation in a way that could put identifiers outside the regulation, with the company deciding. The Council's release describes the pseudonymisation provision as a clarification that helps compliance, and it says the definition of personal data is maintained. Both documents are public. They do not say the same thing about the same words. A reader who wants the fight can hold them side by side. A reader who wants the law in force can hold neither, because neither is law in force.the key stays with the holder.
What the press release will own
The Council lists more than the AI paragraph. It mentions a principle-based definition of scientific research, a longer deadline to report a personal-data breach, a single EU list of high-risk processing, templates for obligations, changes to cookie rules, repeal of parts of the platform-to-business regulation, and a single point for reporting cyber and data incidents. The AI language is one block in that list, described as safeguards plus clarifications on the lawful ground. noyb's post is about the AI block and about pseudonyms, not about the reporting portal. Scope is part of accuracy. This page will not let the portal stand in for the AI fight, or the AI fight erase the portal.a TLS certificate binds a different fact.
Parliament is the missing chamber
noyb says the Parliament has not settled its position, that the Commission is the third party in the talks, and that a court challenge is possible if a final text has no meaningful limit. The Council release does not claim the regulation has been adopted. Agreement inside the Council is how a negotiation starts from that side. It is famous, in this system, for being mistaken for the end. The end is a text Parliament and Council both accept, published, and applied. None of those steps is the October 21 press release.eMudhra's exit is a different row.
What this page will not smooth
It will not quote Schrems as the Council. It will not quote the Council's phrase about maintaining protection as if noyb had conceded. It will not treat a tracker's printing as a substitute if a later official PDF shows a different article. It will not describe the text as a blank check in this paper's own voice. Blank check is noyb's argument. Legitimate interest plus a duty to choose a ground plus a right to object is the tracker's printing of the draft. The distance between those sentences is the story.what an advisory must name.
Who is in scope
People in the European Union whose personal data a company might later process under a final version of this article. Controllers who train or run AI systems, as the parties the draft addresses, if it becomes law. Members of the European Parliament, as the chamber noyb says has not finished. Companies outside any final text's reach are not in scope yet, because there is no final text. Nobody's rights changed on October 23 by the publication of noyb's post.
What stays on the record
Council press release, October 21, 2026, updated October 22 with the mandate. Negotiating position, not adoption. Protection described as maintained. Personal-data definition described as maintained. Pseudonymisation provision described as a clarification. AI language described as safeguards and lawful-ground clarifications. EUTechReg printing of Article 88bis in ST 13886/26: legitimate interest, duty to choose a ground, safeguards including objection. noyb, October 23: expropriation reading, Schrems quotes, Parliament still ahead. Not in force.
What would move the row
The official PDF of the mandate if it differs from the tracker, a Parliament position, or a published regulation would each replace a piece of this row. A correction from noyb or from the Council about pseudonymisation would narrow that dispute. Until then the record is the press release, the tracker's article text, and noyb's October 23 reading.the advisory is the story.
Sources
The reports this brief is filing. Futureweb did not republish them.
Questions
Is Article 88bis the law today?
No. The Council's October 21 release is a position for negotiations. noyb says the European Parliament has not taken a final position and that the text still has to go through talks with Parliament and the Commission. A mandate binds the Council's negotiators. It does not bind a company tonight.
What does the printed article say?
EUTechReg prints ST 13886/26 as saying processing of personal data in developing or operating an AI system or model may be carried out for a legitimate interest under Article 6(1)(f), that this does not remove the duty to choose an appropriate lawful ground, and that such processing still needs safeguards, including the right to object under Article 21.
What does noyb say those sentences do?
noyb says the commercial interests of AI companies would generally trump fundamental rights, that consent would not be required, and that the references to existing articles do not add material safeguards because those duties exist anyway. That is noyb's reading of the same neighborhood of text. It is not the Council press release's summary.
What does the Council's own release emphasize?
The release says the mandate keeps a high level of protection, maintains the current definition of personal data, adds a provision on pseudonymisation, and introduces safeguards on a derogation for sensitive data in biometric verification and in AI development. It describes the AI language as clarifications on the lawful ground and on safeguards. It does not use noyb's word expropriation.
Who is Max Schrems in this story?
He is noyb's face on the October 23 post, and the post quotes him calling the text a gift to large technology companies. The quotes are advocacy. They are on the record as his. They are not a recital in the Council document.